Side-polished SMS based RI sensor employing macro-bending perfluorinated POF

A refractive index (RI) sensor based on perfluorinated plastic optical fiber (PF-POF) is introduced in this paper. The PFPOF as multi-mode fiber was side-polished (SP) to form a macro-bending single-mode-multimode-single-mode (SMS) structure. Both ends of the sensor were closely connected to single-mode quartz optical fiber (SMF). The spectral characteristics of the sensor are measured, analyzed and discussed. The results show that when the length of PF-POF is 8 cm, the macro-bending radius is 3 cm, and the SP-depth is 20 μm. The intensity sensitivity reaches −219.504 dBm/RIU in the range of RI = 1.330 ~ 1.356. A reference is provided for the application of PF-POF in RI sensor in the future. The sensor is featured with low-cost, good flexibility and high efficiency.


Introduction
Fluoropolymer is a straight chain alkane polymer that some or all hydrogen atoms of molecular structure are replaced by fluorine. Fluoropolymer is believed to be a preferred material for the high chemical resistance, barrier property, non-moisture absorption and weather resistance to prepare optical fiber cable, chemical resistant lining, electronic components, coating material and weather resistant film 1 . Compared with quartz optical fiber, PF-POF has many advantages, including good flexibility, low-cost and easy to operate. Compared with PMMA-POF, the lower water absorption of PF-POF makes it is more suitable for working in water or water solution 2 . The advantages of PF-POF are suitable for developing sensors with better performance. It has great potential in the field of developing optical fiber sensing, which is worthy of further research.
RI, an inherent optical property, can directly reflect concentration, purity, viscosity and other information of the solution. Therefore, it has been applied in various fields such as medical diagnosis and chemical analysis 3,4 . The mode interference fiber optic sensor has the advantages of anti-electromagnetic interference and real-time on-line measurement compared with the traditional RI sensing method, including critical angle method, Abbe refractometer and spectrometer. It is an effective means to measure the RI of the solution, and has been studied with growing interests in recent years. At present, there are many types of fiber RI sensors reported, such as surface plasmon resonance (SPR) 5,6 , corrosion SMS 7,8 , and fiber grating 9−11 . However, SPR needs to be coated, and the process is rather complicated; the depth of corrosion cannot be accurately controlled. In addition, hydrogen fluoride corrosion agent is toxic; the price of fiber grating is high, and the quartz fiber is fragile. As a result, extra care is required during the production of the sensor.
The maximum core RI of Graded-index PF-POF (Giga-POF50SR) of 1.356 and the cladding RI of 1.342. PF-POF can be well connected with quartz fiber for low loss, high bandwidth and flexibility. In addition, fluorine molecule has low volatility, which makes the fiber remain stable at high temperature 12 . In terms of practicability, compared with taper 13,14 and etched SMS 15 , the sensor can work stably in water for a long time due to the development and utilization of new material perfluoropolymer, which is obviously practical in the field of liquid detection. In terms of performance, compared with thin core fiber 16 and no-core fiber 17 , the sensor has high sensitivity. With the development of perfluoropolymers, the sensitivity of the sensor will be further improved, and the measurement range will also increase with the core refractive index.
In this paper, SMF and new material PF-POF are used to make SMS structure. On the basis of SMS structure, PF-POF is polished by grindstone. Different from the Vgroove polishing technology 18 , grindstone polishing is a simple and effective method, which can flexibly control the SP-length and SP-depth. The main parameters that affect the sensitivity of the sensor are studied. The RI sensor with optimal parameters has the characteristics of high flexibility, simple processing, high sensitivity and low cost.

Principle
The light in the untreated PF-POF cannot penetrate the cladding and interact with the external environment. Therefore, it is necessary to improve the sensitivity of optical fiber by SP. In order to improve the performance of the sensor, the model is established as shown in Fig.  1(a) to study the influence of fiber structure modification on the sensitivity. From left to right, SP-area can be divided into two parts: the area where the core diameter gradually decreases and increases. Because the SP-area is symmetric, only the light guiding properties of the area with decreased diameter are analyzed. The radius of the clamping wheel is about 15 cm, which is much larger than that of PF-POF. Therefore, the SP-radian drop and rise can be equivalent to drop or rise linearly, as shown in the red dotted line in the Fig. 1(a). The measurement principle of the sensor and the key parameters affecting sensitivity are analyzed from following two aspects.

Evanescent-wave
When total internal reflection occurs in the fiber, the light wave is not absolutely reflected back to the core, but penetrates into the surface of the cladding layer (about one wavelength), propagates along the interface for a short distance, and finally returns to the core. The wave passing through the cladding interface is called evanescent wave 19 . The evanescent depth is expressed as follows: where λ is the wavelength, n 1 is the core RI, and n 2 is the cladding RI. The incident angle at the core-cladding interface is called θ and the SP-depth is D. In this SP-model, the cladding is removed and the external solution acts as a new cladding. Figure 1(b) describes the light propagation path in the SP-area. α is the slope angle of the SP-surface, θ 0 is the angle between the light and the core center line, and L is the SP-length of the falling area. The incident angle of light at the SP-interface for the first time (hereinafter referred to as the incident angle) is θ 1 , and the incident angle for the i th time is recorded as θ i . Then, θ i can be expressed as: It can be seen from Eq. (1) that when n 1 > n 2 , the evanescent depth is increasing with the increased external environment RI, and the spectral intensity decreases continuously with the increase of the penetration depth. This means that the change of external solution RI can be detected from the change of transmission spectrum intensity.
With the decrease of the incident angle and the increase of the SP-length, the evanescent wave effect is enhanced. According to Eq. (2), the incident angle is determined by SP-depth and SP-radian. Therefore, the sensitivity of the sensor can be improved by properly increasing the SP-depth, SP-radian and SP-length. It should be noted that the enhancement of evanescent wave effect caused by the increase of SP-length, SP-depth and SP-radian will lead to the decrease of the overall intensity of the output spectrum.

Refraction effect
In the SP-model, the external environment becomes a new cladding, and the transmitted light will refract under certain conditions. According to Fresnel equation and electromagnetic theory 20 , it can be concluded that the reflected light intensity I' and the refracted light intensity I'' are: where n 01 is the relative RI of the external environment and the core, and θ is the incident angle. The incident light is decomposed into light with S-polarization and Ppolarization whose electric vector is perpendicular to and parallel to the incident plane. The light intensity of them is expressed by I S and I P, respectively. If the intensity of incident light is 1 mW, I S =I P =0.5 mW. The relationship between the intensity of reflected light and refracted light and the relative RI is shown in Fig. 2. It can be seen from Fig. 2 that when sin θ ≥ n 01 , total internal reflection occurs, and the reflected light intensity is 1 mW. When sinθ < n 01 ≤ 1, with the increase of n 01 , the intensity of reflected light begins to decrease; when n 01 =1, the intensity becomes zero. In this process, the change rate gradually decreases; when n 01 > 1, the reflected light intensity increases from zero, and the slope of increasing is small. Therefore, the change of external environment RI can be detected from the intensity change of transmission spectrum. Different incident angle will induce different reflected light intensity, but no matter what the incident angle is (θ < 90°), when the relative RI decreases from 1, the reflected light intensity always increases with the decrease of relative RI.
The relationship between reflected light intensity and incident angle is shown in Fig. 3. Either n 1 < n 0 or n 1 > n 0 , with the increase of incident angle, the reflected light intensity will increase, and the refracted light intensity will decrease. In addition, the refraction effect area increases with the increase of the SP-length L. Therefore, the sensor sensitivity can be improved by increasing the SP-depth, SP-radian and SP-length.

Experimental and preparation
As shown in Fig. 4, the experimental setup contains ASE broadband light source, spectrometer, RI sensor and glycerin aqueous solution with different RI. The cross section  of PF-POF is shown in Fig. 5(a). Regarding connecting PF-POF to SMF or instruments effectively and reliably, the traditional method, UV curing bonding, is reliable. But this method is time-consuming, and highly dependent on the operator experience. Here, the butt joint method of ceramic sleeve 21 is applied, and the connection diagram is shown in Fig. 5(b). This method ensures the accurate connection of optical fiber with low connection loss. Besides, this method is easy to operate and time-saving. Finally, the joint gap of the sleeve is coated with epoxy resin AB glue to avoid solution penetration. At present, the main methods to make optical fiber sensitive to external RI are as follows: taper 13,14 , no-core fiber 22 , D-shaped 23 , Microbend 24 and hydrogen fluoride corrosion 18 . However, all of the above methods have some defects. The taper of optical fiber is difficulted to control and the optical fiber gets thinned and is fragile after being tapered. For no-core fiber, in order to im-prove the sensitivity of sensor, a thin film is needed to be coated on the surface of the fiber. D-shaped and microbend are complex in operation. The corrosion depth is difficult to control for hydrogen fluoride corrosion.
The precision polishing device is shown in Fig. 6, PF-POF is fixed on the semicircular clamping wheel. The ends of POF is connected by optical power meter and light source. Whether the fiber core is polished is determined by optical power measured by a power meter when the move of clampling wheel is controlled by the guide. At this time, the descending distance at the other end of the guide is recorded, which is the SP-depth by microscope after polishing.

Experimental analysis
The transmission spectrum of multimode interference in SMS is related to the length of multimode fiber 21 . SPtreatment can only slightly reduce the overall intensity of transmission spectrum, and will not affect the waveform. Whether the characteristic wavelength can be quickly found is one of the factors to evaluate the performance of sensor. The length of PF-POF can change the shape of spectrum by affecting the mode interference of light field, thus affecting the difficulty of peak finding and sensing performance, so the length characteristics of PF-POF are explored. The relationship between the length of PF-POF and transmission spectrum is studied. Fig. 7 shows the transmission spectra of PF-POF with length of 5 cm, 6 cm, 7 cm, 8 cm and 9 cm respectively. Due to the obvious multimode interference effect, complex interference spectrum appears. With the change of PF-POF length, the interference fringes also change. As shown in the red dotted box in Fig. 7, when the length of PF-POF is 8 cm, the spectral notch depth is more obvious, which is suitable for the measurement of RI.
Since the radius of the side wheel is determined in this experiment, the SP-length is positively correlated with the SP-depth, so only the SP-depth is explored. The sensor is explored under the conditions of different SPdepth. Figure 8 shows the transmission spectra in air and  Figure 8(d) shows that the SPdepth is not good to be too large. When D =30 μm, due to the large SP-depth, the fiber core is so thin that the optical energy loss is too high and the signal-to-noise ratio is reduced. As a result, it is not suitable for measurement and observation. The effect of macro-bending on the sensor is explored. Macro-bending can change the incident angle and the SP-radian. The bending of the sensor with the same direction and SP-radian is defined as the same direction bending (SDB), as shown in Fig. 9(a); the bending of the sensor and with the opposite direction and SP-radian direction is defined as the opposite direction bending (ODB), as shown in Fig. 9(b). Figure 10 shows the transmission spectra in air and glycerin aqueous solution (RI = 1.356) under different bending directions and radius conditions when the PF-POF length is 8 cm and the SP-depth is 20 μm. In the environment with same RI difference, the intensity sensitivity increases with the decrease of bending radius. The intensity change of Fig. 10(a) is 7.688 dBm, which is higher than 7.012 dBm in Fig. 10(b); the intensity drift of Fig. 10(c) is 12.750 dBm, which is higher than 9.068 dBm in Fig. 10(d). The sensitivity of the sensor can be improved by bending with proper radius. Besides, it can also be seen that the performance of SDB is better than that of ODB. With the decrease of bending radius, the mode of light gradually changes from higher order to lower order, and the higher-order modes gradually leak    out from the core. As a result, the loss increases, the overall intensity of the output spectrum decreases and the wavelength sensitivity increases 25 . In addition, bending changes the RI distribution of PF-POF, thus changing the mode field distribution of the light, resulting in spectral shifts. The transmission spectrum intensity of Fig. 10(e) and Fig. 10(f) is weak and the signal-to-noise ratio is reduced, which indicates that the ultra-small bending radius is not good for the sensing. As nearly half of fiber is polished, the bending stress on the SP-area and the normal area is not uniform. This phenomenon becomes obvious gradually with the decrease of bending radius. If the bending radius is too small, the PF-POF will change from the ori-ginal arc shape to the triangular shape, as shown in Fig.  11. This phenomenon leads to the decrease of transmission intensity and signal-to-noise ratio, which is not suitable for measurement and observation. The results show that the SDB structure with R=3 cm is a better choice.
A RI sensor with 8 cm of PF-POF length, 20 μm of SPdepth and 3 cm of SDB radius were fabricated. The RI sensing performance of sensor is studied in the range of 1.330-1.356 with 0.005RIU as the interval. As shown in Fig. 12, the black dotted line depicts the nonlinear change trend of the intensity value of the characteristic wavelength in different RI solutions. It can be seen that when the external RI becomes smaller from 1.356 (the relative RI of the measured solution and the fiber core is 1), the intensity of the characteristic wavelength increases with the decrease of the RI, and the increase rate is becoming larger. This phenomenon verifies the conclusion of the section: Principle. When the relative RI is 1, all the energy passing through the SP-interface will be refracted out. However, a small amount of light waves in the fiber will not pass through the SP-interface, but is directly coupled to the SMF and detected by the spectrometer, so the intensity of the characteristic wavelength is  It can be concluded from theoretical analysis and experimental results that the sensitivity of the sensor has high sensitivity and linearity when the RI of the external solution is less than that of the fiber core. The sensitivity can be improved by properly modifying the structure of the sensor, such as SP and macro-bending.
The temperature characteristics of the RI sensor are researched from 10 °C to 40 °C. The PF-POF length is 8 cm, the SP-depth is 20 μm. The sensor is of SDB structure with R=3 cm. The intensity variation shown in Fig.  13(a) presents a linear sensitivity of 0.127 dBm/°C. The measured wavelength shift presents a linear sensitivity of 0.803 nm/°C with the temperature rising, as shown in Fig. 13(b). PF-POF has large thermo-optic coefficient and thermal expansion coefficient 12 . The length and numerical aperture of PF-POF will change when temperature changes, which will lead to the change of propagation constant of intrinsic mode and the drift of interference fringes. The results show that the temperature affects the performance of the sensor. In the RI sensing experiment mentioned above, the ambient temperature is stable to reduce the influence of temperature fluctuation and realize high-precision RI measurement. The RI sensor needs temperature compensation before practical application.

Conclusion
In this work, RI sensor based on PF-POF with different characteristic parameters was successfully fabricated. The sensor with the intensity sensitivity of −219.504 dBm/RIU in the range of RI=1.330−1.356 was prepared (PF-POF length=8 cm, SDB R=3 cm and SP-depth=20 μm). The results indicate that the accomplishment of accurate measurement of RI sensor requires appropriate correction and temperature compensation impeded by the large thermo-optic coefficient and the thermal expansion coefficient of PF-POF. Since the perfluorinated plastic optical fiber refractive index sensor has good flexibility, high mechanical strength, simple manufacture and low price, it has wide application prospect in water conservancy, food detection and other fields.